Blue Paul Terrier vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison

Blue Paul Terrier is originated from United Kingdom but Anatolian Shepherd is originated from Turkey. Blue Paul Terrier may grow 20 cm / 7 inches shorter than Anatolian Shepherd. Blue Paul Terrier may weigh 43 kg / 94 pounds lesser than Anatolian Shepherd. Both Blue Paul Terrier and Anatolian Shepherd has almost same life span. Both Blue Paul Terrier and Anatolian Shepherd has same litter size. Blue Paul Terrier requires Low maintenance. But Anatolian Shepherd requires Moderate maintenance

History

Known also as the Scottish Bull Terrier, the Blue Poll or the Blue Poll Bulldog, the Blue Paul Terrier’s origins, as with many unusual dog breeds, are still not known precisely. However they do appear to have been bred with Staffies at some point and appear to have slowly transformed into the Staffie or Pit Bull as we know them today.

There doesn’t seem to be much documentation on the dog’s origins, making many stories of its origins to be looked upon as folklore. It seems as if the dog originated out of Scotland. The name ‘Paul’ is included in the name simply because it is believed that John Paul Jones, who was a sailor, brought the dog to the USA in 1777.

Because this dog has superb fighting skills, it was introduced as part of Staffordshire Bull Terrier breeding in the early 19th century. It is believed that the first dogs came with English immigrants to the United Stated in the middle of the 19th century. At some time, the dog became extinct, but dates of this time can’t be established.

anatolian shepherd - historyUp in the mountains of central Turkey, in the region called Anatolia, a large, strong and rugged dog breed was born and is honored today on a postal stamp. This was the Anatolian Shepard – keeper of the flocks with strength, agility and speed. The Anatolian Shepard is able to pursue and catch any predator that threatens his livestock and they are his livestock. His keen sense of hearing and his excellent sight only add to his prowess as a protector.

The Anatolian is a giant dog, classified as a shepherd by the UKC – Kennel Club of the United Kingdom, while he is classified as a mountain dog or molossus by the Federation Cynologique International. When the breed was created, they were a gift to the farmers in the mountains to guard the livestock from cheetahs. This helped the cheetahs to stop attacking the livestock and prevented the farmers from wiping out the cheetah population by shooting them.

The Anatolian Shepard does have some controversy in his lineage as in some areas he is considered to be either the most closely related or the same breed as the Turkish Kangal Dog. The Anatolian is considered to have a blood line that goes back at least 6000 years.

They are direct descendants of mastiffs and mountain dogs. Yet they have the long legs, agility and aloofness of the sight hounds that are also in their bloodline. Originally called the “Coban Kopegi” or shepherd dog by their Turkish farmers, they were eventually separated into the breed called the Anatolian Shepard. When the breed was first brought into the United Kingdom the line of the Kangal dog was first. Then they were crossed with dogs called Anatolian Shepherds. Many breeders believe that the Anatolian Shepherd is a category that includes the Kangal, Coban Kopegi, Aksaray Malaklisi and the Akbash dog.

So as of January 2012, the Australian National Kennel Club no longer considers the Anatolian Shepard and the Kangal as separate breeds. The UK Kennel Club now recognizes the Kangal and the Anatolian as the same breed. For others they are still clearly separate and distinct breeds with the ASD being their own breed. In fact, the government of Turkey recognizes them as separate breeds and the Kangal Dog as the National Dog of Turkey.

The Anatolian Shepard was already in the United States in when the Anatolian Shepard Club of America came into being because of a young naval officer who had met the dogs in Turkey. They were allowed into the Miscellaneous Class of the American Kennel Club in 1996 after this naval officer had been breeding them in California for years. By 1998 they had moved to the Working Group where they reside today.

Description

Staffie/Pit Bull Look Alike

The Blue Paul Terrier was a smooth coated, medium sized dog. His coat was mostly dark blue but this sometimes varied to red or brindle. He was a muscled and well built dog, much like our pit bull terriers. He weighed about 20 to 25kg kg, measuring up to 56cm at the withers. He had a broad chest, large head with small cropped ears and a tail that was set low. He is a dog that always stood strongly on his legs. It seems as if he had an aggressive nature as they were used by local dog fighters.

Aggressive by Nature

There is not much information on the temperament of the Blue Paul Terrier, but we can assume, that because he was a Terrier, he would have been full of character and self confidence. Most Terriers don’t actively look for a fight, but will certainly get into a fight if provoked. Aggressive by nature and a fighter, the Blue Paul Terrier possibly had some Staffordshire Bull Terrier in him, so his temperament would be that of a fighter.

He may have been able to live peacefully with children and other dogs and cats in the home, but he would no doubt have had to be raised from a puppy in such a household. Stubborn and headstrong, he would require a firm owner who could take charge of him and training would have been imperative for such a dog.

anatolian shepherd puppy - descriptionComing from the mountains and guarding their flock against cheetahs has led the Anatolian Shepherd to be a muscular dog with broad heads and thick necks and sturdy, strong bodies. Their ears drop and are triangular in shape, while their muzzles are rectangular with tight lips. Their double coat is thick and warm fitting for life in the mountain regions. They do blow their coats with excessive shedding twice a year. The fur on their throat is extra thick for their protection.

Muscular, thin, their rib cage is large while their stomach is small. Their tails can be intact or docked. The Anatolian Shepherd is much like the Kuvasz or the Great Pyrenees in their size, shape and responsibilities. He is more agile and slenderer than those two dogs. Their bite is scissors or level, while their eyes are almonds, set apart in their heads.

Characteristics

Nobody is quite certain what the Blue Paul Terrier was like. He definitely seemed to be a mix of Pit Bull and Staffie – the same compact, muscular build with a look that speaks of confidence and boldness.

Perhaps if the Blue Paul Terrier wasn’t used for fighting, he might well have made a good pet with training and socialization. Nobody really knows. Maybe he was so aggressive that when dog fighting didn’t work out, and it was discovered that he wasn't really pet-material, nobody bothered when the breed went into extinction. That's the thing with Blue Paul Terriers, nobody is really certain about what they were really like.

anatolian shepherd dog - characteristicsThis breed is independent, stubborn and strong. They are great protectors of their flocks and people, but they are incredibly challenging to own. They are intelligent, loyal dogs who learn quickly when they want to. They key being “when they want to”. The Anatolian Shepard was bred to be nomadic, following the herd and hunting for the herd’s predators. Microchip your ASD because they will roam if they get the chance.

If you want your Anatolian to get along with other dogs, cats or other animals, socialize them together when the ASD is a puppy. If the animal or child is part of his flock the ASD will protect them with his life. Though he is loving, quiet and calm, the Anatolian is just as demanding and dominating. Never let your Anatolian Shepherd believe that he is above the humans in the pack or you will have a major problem controlling him. He will be especially leery of strangers and will not accept your word that the stranger is part of the family. However, if she understands that humans are above her and you are the leader, she will accept any person you accept.

Even if they accept strangers, they will not allow anyone other than the family into the home when the owner is not there. This is a proud, proud dog that can be stubborn, demanding and bossy. Being such a large dog, you need to be in control. This is not a dog for everyone. Be firm, confident, be loving and consistent when training an Anatolian Shepherd. Do not offer your ASD any additional training in protection. He doesn’t need it and it could be detrimental. They will protect children, but they do not respect them. Therefore, supervise their interactions with children.

Health Problems

The Blue Paul Terrier Health was generally a healthy dog, but he would no doubt have had the same common dog ailments that most dog breeds have to contend with. All those years ago, when the Blue Paul Terrier was ill, his owner no doubt would have taken him to see the veterinarian for a full screening.

Just like with other dog breeds, he would have been watched for hip dysplasia , ticks and fleas, cataracts and skin infections. It is possible that in those days, owners of the Blue Paul Terrier weren’t aware of how plaque could cause dental problems or gum disease.

anatolian shepherd puppies - health problemsThis is a healthy breed without a lot of the issues that plaque other giant breeds. In one recent survey the leading cause of death among the ASD is cancer and old age. Skin issues are more prevalent than dysplasia though it does occur. They have a sensitivity to anesthesia and their immune system does take longer to mature so all young ASD should be discussed with vets before any vaccinations are given. Bloat is not as common among this breed either. They should be screened for eyelid inversion or entropion. They are susceptible to Demodectic Mange or demodicosis which is caused by a mite.

Caring The Pet

Feed

Because these dogs were used in fighting, it is a breed that no doubt would have required plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to keep him fighting fit. No doubt he would have received a high quality food to build up his strength and stamina. Because he was no doubt a high energy dog, his owners would have had to give him nutritious food and ensured fresh, clean water for him.

Grooming

The Blue Paul Terrier had a short, smooth coat, so they were no doubt low maintenance dogs who received a brush down every now and then to remove his loose hair.

Feeding

anatolian shepherd dogs - caringFeed your Anatolian Shepherd a measured amount twice a day and keep him from becoming overweight. It is recommended that you feed her from 4-6 cups of dry, high quality food for the entire day. The more active your dog is, the more she will need to eat. Using treats in training is appropriate but don’t give her too many as these will add to the waist line.

Health issues

As mentioned previously this is a very healthy breed especially when compared with other giant and/or mountain dog breeds. However, they are susceptible but not prone to:

Hip Dysplasia

Should be tested for this condition in which the bones don’t fit well into the joint. Elbow Dysplasia – the same as above except it is the arm bone does not fit well into the joint. Both these conditions can cause arthritis or lameness.

Demodectic Mange

Caused by mites and a weakened immune system it can result in patches of scaly, red skin and hair loss. A generalized version can cover the entire body and can be fatal.

Hypothyroidism

This can result if obesity, hair loss, epilepsy, lethargy and other skin condition. It is easily treatable.

Entropion

Mentioned previously it causes the eyelid to roll inward and requires surgery.

Exercise and games

Your Anatolian Shepherd does not need a lot of exercise despite his size. A large yard with a good fence will do for him as long as he gets a walk daily. If they can run free in a large yard they will be happy. If not, you will need to take them to a dog park, preferable when other dogs are NOT present. You can’t assume he will be ok with other dogs. Never walk them off leash as they love to wander. They need a job to do.

Basic Information

Group:
Terrier dog
Working dog
Origin:
United Kingdom
Turkey
Height Male:
48 - 56 cm
18 - 23 inches
71 - 76 cm
27 - 30 inches
Height Female:
48 - 56 cm
18 - 23 inches
66 - 71 cm
25 - 28 inches
Weight Male:
20 - 25 kg
44 - 56 pounds
45 - 68 kg
99 - 150 pounds
Weight Female:
20 - 25 kg
44 - 56 pounds
41 - 59 kg
90 - 131 pounds
Life Span:
9 - 12 Years
10 - 11 Years
Litter Size:
2 - 10
5 - 10
Size:
Medium dog
Giant dog
Other Names:
Scottish Bull Terrier, the Blue Poll or the Blue Poll Bulldog
Karabaş (Blackhead), Anatolian Blackhead (Anadolulu Karabaş), Kangal Coban Kopegi • Perro de pastor de Anatolia • Anatolischer Hirtenhund • Chien de berger d'Anatolie • Anatolian Shepard Dog or ASD
Colors Available:
Dark blue, red, brindle
fawn, brindle
Coat:
short and smooth
Double, thick, rough
Shedding:
Minimal
Seasonal
Temperament:
Affectionate, Aggressive, Alert, Courageous, Energetic, Friendly, Independent, Intelligent, Lively, Loyal, Outgoing, Playful, Protective, Responsive, Social, Territorial
Alert, Courageous, Detached, Independent, Intelligent, Loving, Loyal, Protective, Quiet, Stubborn, Territorial
Grooming:
Low maintenance
Moderate maintenance
Trainability:
Moderate
Easy
Hypoallergenic:
No
No
Kids Friendly:
No
No
New Owners Friendly:
Yes
No

Comparison with other breeds

  1. Bernese Mountain Dog vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  2. Newfoundland Dog vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  3. Leonberger vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  4. Alaunt vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  5. Alangu Mastiff vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  6. Pyrenean Mastiff vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  7. Bisben vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  8. Moscow Watchdog vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  9. Spanish Mastiff vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  10. St. Bernard vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  11. Kars Dog vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  12. Moscow Water Dog vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  13. Ciobanesc de Bucovina vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  14. Great Dane vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  15. English Mastiff vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  16. Neapolitan Mastiff vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  17. Anatolian Shepherd vs American Mastiff - Breed Comparison
  18. Anatolian Shepherd vs American Molossus - Breed Comparison
  19. Anatolian Shepherd vs American Staghound - Breed Comparison
  20. Bully Kutta vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  21. Irish Wolfhound vs Anatolian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  22. Bull Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  23. Schnauzer vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  24. Fox Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  25. Bull and Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  26. Irish Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  27. Fox Terrier (Smooth) vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  28. Kerry Blue Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  29. Lakeland Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  30. Jagdterrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  31. Blue Paul Terrier vs American Pit Bull Terrier - Breed Comparison
  32. Blue Paul Terrier vs Airedale Terrier - Breed Comparison
  33. Blue Paul Terrier vs Bedlington Terrier - Breed Comparison
  34. Blue Paul Terrier vs Austrian Pinscher - Breed Comparison
  35. Blue Paul Terrier vs Atlas Terrier - Breed Comparison
  36. Indian Bull Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  37. Irish Bull Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  38. Japanese Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  39. Brazilian Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  40. Old English Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  41. Scoland Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  42. Skye Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  43. Irish Staffordshire Bull Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  44. Soft-Coated Wheaten Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  45. Staffordshire Bull Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison
  46. Welsh Terrier vs Blue Paul Terrier - Breed Comparison

View/Compare Breeds

Popular Dog Breeds