Irish Setter vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison

Irish Setter vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed ComparisonIrish Setter is originated from Ireland but Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) is originated from Belgium. Both Irish Setter and Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) are having almost same height. Both Irish Setter and Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) are of same weight. Both Irish Setter and Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) has almost same life span. Both Irish Setter and Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) has almost same litter size. Irish Setter requires Moderate maintenance. But Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) requires Low maintenance

History

irish setter - historyThe Irish Setter is a gun dog, originating in Ireland and recognized by his beautiful red or mahogany coat.

Descending from the Setter group, the Irish Setter, also known as the Red Setter, has a solid pedigree. It was in the 1800s that they were brought to the United States.

The Irish Setter wasn't always what it looks like today and in fact the solid red color was created because of selective breeding practices. The Irish Setter has long medium length floppy ears, brown eyes and he is deep chested.

belgian shepherd dog malinois - historyThe Belgian Malinois is one of 4 Belgian Shepherd varieties. The dogs were developed- and hail from Belguim. The Malinois has a short, fawn colored coat. The American Kennel Club recognizes that the Malinois is a separate breed from the other 3 varieties. It was in 1892 that Professor Reul wrote the first Belgian Shepherd Dog standard, recognizing 3 varieties – dogs with short coats, dogs with long coats and dogs with rough coats.

Today's Malinois goes back to a breeding pair owned by Adrien Janssens. It was in 1885 that he bought a fawn, rough-haired dog, breeding the dog with a short-haired dog named Lise de Laeken. After other breedings, the two dogs were recognized as ancestors of the modern Belgian Shepherd Dogs.

The city of Malines formed a club for the promotion of these fawn short hairs and the name Malinois became synonymous with them. In March 1992, the American Belgian Malinois Club received AKC parent club status.

Description

irish setter puppy - descriptionThe Irish Setter is a large dog, beautiful and elegant looking, standing at 61 to 71cm in height and weighing anything from 25 to 34kg, males and females.

The coat is a rich red color and is short to medium length but feathers in places such as the tail, the chest and abdomen, the legs and the tail. The head is long and lean, the ears are long and silky and the tail long and feathery.

Temperament:

The Irish Setter is a playful, friendly, sweet, mischievous, high energy dog who makes a superb family pet, getting on well with children in the home.

It was noticed that in about 1845, Setters in Ireland were mostly red, red and white or even a mustardy-lemon type of color, but there was preference for the solid red coloring. The breed standard for the modern Irish Setter was drawn up in Dublin by the Irish Red Setter Club and approved in 1886.

The dog was essentially bred for hunting game birds, using their excellent sense of smell to locate the bird. He is an alert, intelligent dog and will learn easily. Training and socialization will make him obedient and relaxed.

He isn't an assertive kind of breed and therefore isn't going to make the best of watchdogs. They've got such amicable, kind temperaments that they make popular therapy dogs.

Similarities to German Shepherd

belgian shepherd dog malinois puppy - descriptionThe Malinois is a medium-size Belgian shepherd dog. People sometimes mistake them for the German Shepherd as they are fairly similar to look at. The Malinois however is a smaller, lighter boned dog with naturally upright ears and a black-masked face. He is shorthaired and fawn-colored with black tips on the hairs, although other colors are brown or red too. He is an intelligent and active dog, always having been used for herding-, police- and rescue work.

Reserved or Friendly

You’ll find the Malinois somewhat unpredictable as some are friendly and confident while other can be shy and withdrawn around strangers. This is a dog who loves to be around his human family, but to bring out the best in him, training and socialization classes will be necessary. Well-socialized Malinois are always good with children and other pets, more so if they’ve been raised with them.

Characteristics

irish setter dog - characteristicsIrish Setters are going to make you a wonderful pet. He has a friendly, confident disposition that makes them ideal pets for families with children who have been taught how to respect- and be kind to animals.

He is a big dog, but with training and socialization he becomes well behaved and obedient. Social and outgoing, this is a dog which just loves the companionship of their human family and will require a good deal of exercise too.

Keep him well exercised, feed him good food that promotes health, give him a nice warm, dry place to sleep and he’ll fit perfectly well into your family and make a splendid pet.

belgian shepherd dog malinois dog - characteristicsThe Belgian Malinois makes a wonderful guard dog and he works hard to ensure that his human family, whom he adores, are well protected under his watch. They’re such intelligent dogs too that you may feel inclined to pass over some of your chores to him.

He responds well to training, and to get the best from this breed, start with training and socialization as soon as you bring your puppy home.

Socialization is excellent as it introduces your puppy to different people, animals as well as situations.

He is an adaptable dog and can live in an apartment if he is well exercised. He can be your devoted and loyal friend for a good number of years but you will have to do your part in providing him with the best care possible.

Health Problems

irish setter puppies - health problemsIrish Setters are quite a healthy breed but they are also prone to getting some of the common dog illnesses such as hip dysplasia, cancer, bloat and canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency.

Canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency:

Known as CLAD, this is a disease of the immune system found in Irish Setters. True, it is a rare disease and affected animals show signs of skin lesions, bone disorders, anorexia and generalized lymphadenopathy.

Bloat:

Irish Setters can develop bloat, a life-threatening condition where the stomach distends with gas and can twist. This is known as gastric torsion and you’ll see your dog’s restlessness. He may even ‘hide away’ somewhere, lying down and drooling, while trying to vomit. This is an illness which requires immediate veterinary intervention.

belgian shepherd dog malinois puppies - health problemsBelgian Malinois are generally healthy dogs. However every dog, regardless of breed, can pick up illnesses, and it is always wise to be aware of some of the diseases your Malinois might face.

Hip Dysplasia

An inherited condition where the thigh bone doesn't fit properly into the hip joint. As the dog ages, arthritis can develop.

Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA)

A degenerative eye disorder that can lead to blindness.

Dental problems

Brush his teeth at least 2 or 3 times a week to remove tartar build-up. Too much plague leads to inflamed gums, bad breath, pus inside the mouth and even loss of teeth.

Caring The Pet

Exercise:

irish setter dogs - caringIrish Setters are lean and muscular and an active breed. They love nothing more than to run off in wide open spaces, and if you live in the city and have a large garden, he will need to be taken on long walks. If he is a country dog, he may well run off and be gone for an hour or two before he returns home.

They are dogs which are used to having a job to do such as hunting, so he won't do well if he is put into a small back yard and left to his own device. He is a social dog and wants to be with his human family, relying on them to include him in all their activities.

Diet:

Your Irish Setters is a lean, muscular, active dog, and to keep him that way he will require a nutritious diet. If you feed him commercially manufactured kibble, make sure it is the very best quality one. It is a good idea to mix in protein such as cooked chicken, brown rice and vegetables. Some raw meat added in from time to time can be very beneficial to him too.

With your beautiful Irish Setter, it is best to avoid feeding your dog processed foods altogether. A good diet is essential for good health. Never leave your dog without a constant supply of cool, fresh water.

Grooming:

The Red Setter’s coat is fairly long on the body but short and smooth on the head. The coat will need to be brushed at least twice a week to prevent matting.

Trim his nails as needed, and find out how to keep his teeth healthy too with vet approved canine dog toothpaste- and brush.

Also check his long, floppy ears because it is so easy for ear infections to develop with these long-eared dogs.

Regular Brushing as he’s a Shedder

belgian shepherd dog malinois dogs - caringBecause the Malinois is a constant shedder, with a couple of heavy shedding periods during the year, you’ll need to be conscientious with his grooming and brush him at least twice a week to get rid of loose hairs and to give his thick coat a glossy, healthy look to it.

Exercise

Because of their high energy, Malinois aren’t recommended for couch-potato type owners. It will be cruel to buy such a dog and to leave him to waste away with boredom and frustration in your back yard. He’ll want lots of rough and tumble, ball games, runs in the park or in the country and long walks.

Feeding

Belgian Shepherd Malinois puppies are vulnerable when they’re tiny, and it would be wise to speak to your vet about superb nutrition to build up a puppy’s immune system.

An excellent way to ensure the health of your growing Malinois is to give him a home prepared meals along with commercially manufactured food recommended by your vet. You can’t just put a bowl of commercially manufactured dog food in front of him day after day month after month.

Apart from what your vet recommends, give him some brown rice, some cooked vegetables and some raw meat. Raw meat will ensure he can fight of skin infections. The age of the dog, emotional state and environmental influences can all play a role in skin diseases with dogs, but by ensuring some raw meat in his diet, the immune system is strengthened and skin disorders are eliminated. Always ensure a steady supply of fresh water.

Basic Information

Group:
Gun dog
Herding dogs
Origin:
Ireland
Belgium
Height Male:
61 - 71 cm
24 - 28 inches
61 - 66 cm
24 - 26 inches
Height Female:
61 - 71 cm
24 - 28 inches
56 - 61 cm
22 - 25 inches
Weight Male:
25 - 34 kg
55 - 75 pounds
29 - 34 kg
63 - 75 pounds
Weight Female:
25 - 34 kg
55 - 75 pounds
25 - 34 kg
55 - 75 pounds
Life Span:
11 - 15 Years
12 - 14 Years
Litter Size:
7 - 12
6 - 10
Size:
Large dog
Medium dog
Other Names:
Red Setter
Mali,Berger Belge Malinois, Mechelse Berger
Colors Available:
Red
Fawn-colored with black tips on the hairs, brown or red
Coat:
Medium Length, silky and feathery
short and dense
Shedding:
Moderate
Constant, Seasonal
Temperament:
Affectionate, Alert, Cheerful, Courageous, Curious, Energetic, Friendly, Gentle, Independent, Intelligent, Lively, Loving, Loyal, Outgoing, Playful, Protective, Responsive, Social, Stubborn, Sweet, Territorial
Affectionate, Alert, Cheerful, Courageous, Curious, Energetic, Friendly, Independent, Intelligent, Lively, Loving, Loyal, Outgoing, Playful, Protective, Social, Territorial
Grooming:
Moderate maintenance
Low maintenance
Trainability:
Easy
Moderate
Hypoallergenic:
No
No
Kids Friendly:
Yes
Yes
New Owners Friendly:
Yes
Yes

Comparison with other breeds

  1. Pembroke Welsh Corgi vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  2. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Australian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  3. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Australian Cattle Dog - Breed Comparison
  4. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Bearded Collie - Breed Comparison
  5. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Austrailian Blue Heeler - Breed Comparison
  6. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Australian Collie - Breed Comparison
  7. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Australian Red Heeler - Breed Comparison
  8. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Australian Stumpy Tail Cattle Dog - Breed Comparison
  9. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Laekenois) - Breed Comparison
  10. Collie vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  11. Dutch Shepherd vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  12. Blue Healer vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  13. English Shepherd vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  14. Catahoula Cur vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  15. Catalan Sheepdog vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  16. Pyrenean Shepherd vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  17. Bergamasco vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  18. Berger Picard vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  19. Appenzell Mountain Dog vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  20. Queensland Heeler vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  21. German Coolie vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  22. Bohemian Shepherd vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  23. Croatian Sheepdog vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  24. Red Heeler vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  25. Belgian Shepherd Dog (Tervuren) vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  26. Irish Setter vs Golden Retriever - Breed Comparison
  27. Irish Setter vs German Shorthaired Pointer - Breed Comparison
  28. Irish Setter vs Bracco Italiano - Breed Comparison
  29. Irish Setter vs Irish Red and White Setter - Breed Comparison
  30. Irish Setter vs Grand Gascon Saintongeois - Breed Comparison
  31. Irish Setter vs Braque Francais (Gascogne Type) - Breed Comparison
  32. Portuguese Pointer vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  33. Perdiguero de Burgos vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  34. Pachon Navarro vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  35. Slovakian Rough Haired Pointer vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  36. Slovensky Hrubosrsty Stavac vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  37. Smooth Haired Weimaraner vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  38. Spanish Pointer vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  39. Spinone Italiano vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  40. Talbot vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  41. Vikhan Sheepdog vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  42. Weimaraner vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  43. Longhaired Weimaraner vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  44. Samoyed vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  45. Labradoodle vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  46. Mixed vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  47. Old English Sheepdog vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  48. Presa Canario vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  49. Labrador Husky vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison
  50. Perro de Presa Canario vs Irish Setter - Breed Comparison

View/Compare Breeds

Popular Dog Breeds