McNab vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison | MyDogBreeds

McNab vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed ComparisonMcNab is originated from United States but Istrian Sheepdog is originated from Slovenia. Both McNab and Istrian Sheepdog are having almost same height. McNab may weigh 10 kg / 22 pounds lesser than Istrian Sheepdog. McNab may live 3 years more than Istrian Sheepdog. Both McNab and Istrian Sheepdog has almost same litter size. McNab requires Low maintenance. But Istrian Sheepdog requires Moderate maintenance

History

mcnab - historyThe attractive McNab dog is also known as the McNab Shepherd or McNab Collie. This very lively dog originated in the Mendocino region of Northern California, being specifically bred to withstand tough weather conditions and rough terrain.

The dog is becoming popular outside of California now. A Scottish rancher with the surname McNab left Scotland and arrived in California in the 19th century. He crossed Scottish Border Collies with Shepherd dogs and the ranchers in California started using these dogs for herding livestock.

Today they are still being used as herding dogs in California and other countries. The dog isn’t recognized by the American Kennel Club. It was in 2014 that a group of McNab Shepherd breeders established the McNab Shepherd Registry so as to work towards the advancement of the McNab Shepherd.

istrian sheepdog - historyKnown also as the Karst Sheepdog, the beautiful, medium sized Istrian Sheepdog hails from Slovenia, Yugoslavia in the 1600s, being used to guard sheep. In fact, the Karst Shepherd was recognized as the Illyrian Shepherd in 1939.

The dog is fairly scarce in his own country, but interest in the dog started developing in the late 1970s. The Fédération Cynologique Internationale recognizes the breed and it has also been exported to the United States, being recognized by the United Kennel Club.

It is also recognized by a number of smaller kennel clubs. The dogs numbers have declined at certain periods in its history but fortunately breeding programs boosted its numbers.

Description

mcnab puppy - descriptionThe McNab Dog is a medium-sized working dog. The appearance of this dog varies quite a bit. For instance you may come across a dog with erect ears or floppy ears or a long tail or one that is naturally bobbed.

When it comes to size, you will find that between the males and females they stand at roughly 40 – 64cm and weigh anything from 14 – 30kg.

Most of these McNabs are black or red with white feet, white tipped tails and white markings around the face. The coat is weather resistant and fairly short and dense. You also get tri-colored McNabs. Eyes are usually a brown or copper color though you might find some with bluish eyes as well.

Temperament:

These are such intelligent dogs so with training and socialization you’ll find he is able to learn easily and quickly. He is a self assured dog, so he will respond well to an owner who is firm and fair, patient, kind and consistent.

He is best suited to life in the country as he needs lots of place to run around. If you don’t live on a farm, take the dog for long walks every day as he requires lots of exercise and mental stimulation. He is a loving family member too, getting along well with kids in the home as well as other pets. He is also a good guard- and watch dog, taking his job as protector of his human family very seriously.

istrian sheepdog puppy - descriptionThis is a medium sized, muscled, strong dog with an iron-grey coat that has shades of deeper grey. His beautiful coat is long, thick and fairly harsh to the touch, with the undercoat protecting the dog against cold weather.

Around the neck area the hair is longer, forming an eye-catching-like mane. The stomach area has longer hair too. He has a noble look about him with kind, brown eyes and a round skull. The muzzle of the dog is dark, the limbs long and muscular and the tail is long and covered in thick fur.

The dog is slightly longer than its height, and both males and females stand at 54 to 63cm in height and weigh between 26 and 40kg. The long tail reaches right down to the hocks. The ears of the dog are fairly short and are floppy.

Temperament:

This dog has always made an excellent guard dog, being alert and also being distrustful of strangers. He will need to be trained and socialized if you want him to be obedient to you and more amicable around children in the home as well as visitors to the home.

If he is trained and well socialized, he is able to make a good pet. However, he is an energetic dog, used to working and he isn't recommended for life in the city if there is only a tiny garden. He needs space and will require a large garden.

He will also need to be exercised and not just left to his own devices in the backyard. Because he is essentially a working dog he doesn’t easily fit into the role of pet and companion. He is a working dog and will need to be kept busy.

Characteristics

mcnab dog - characteristicsThe McNab makes a splendid pet and is known to be even-tempered, being friendly and tolerant with his entire human family.

He gets on well with children in the home as well as other pets. He has always been a hard working pet and doubles up as being an excellent guard dog too. Those who have had the McNab as a pet say that you couldn’t get a more excellent family canine friend.

istrian sheepdog dog - characteristicsYour Istrian Sheepdog is a unique, strong-willed dog that is used to guarding, and working and he wants to be kept involved and busy.

He is wary of strangers and makes an excellent guard dog for any family home. Remember that it is never good to invest in a dog purely for guard dog purposes. A dog such as the Istrian Sheepdog is a social creature and he also wants- and needs to be part of a human family that provides him with plenty of interaction with them.

The Istrian Sheepdog is a loyal, loving dog who is capable of forming strong bonds with his human family. With proper training and socialization he makes a good friend of children and the elderly too.

Include him in all your family activities just like any human family member and he will make you a splendid, courageous pet.

Health Problems

mcnab puppies - health problemsThis dog doesn’t really have genetic health issues, but they can suffer with hip dysplasia, a problem that many dogs battle with, whether small or large, young or old.

They can also suffer with epilepsy and an eye disease such as entropion where the lid of the eye is turned inwards. Check its ears and teeth regularly for infections and keep up to date with his vaccinations.

The McNab is a health dog breed so you aren't likely to face any of these common dog health issues.

istrian sheepdog puppies - health problemsAs with many other dog breeds, the Istrian Sheepdog is a healthy dog that, because of history of hard work, is robust and able to stand up well to common dog illnesses.

However there is one dog illness that strikes many dogs and at any age, and it is hip dysplasia. This is a malformation of the hip joints.

You'll notice that your once active dog is lethargic, doesn't want to play so much anymore and battles to get up after lying down. The disease is painful for your dog and it can lead to mobility issues. The disease is diagnosed with x-rays and your vet will recommend treatment options to make life more comfortable and less painful for your beloved pet.

Caring The Pet

Diet:

mcnab dogs - caringYou can feed your McNab dog commercial dry kibble, but then you want to be sure its the best quality one. Buying inferior foods means that you’re getting a whole lot of ingredients in the food that are bad – sugar, salt, preservatives, fillers, colorants etc. Rather go for the best brands that will ensure that your dog is getting all the vitamins and minerals he needs.

Homemade food is also important and foods such as boiled chicken, brown rice and pasta as well as cooked or raw vegetables chopped up and added to his dry kibble can make for a delicious, wholesome treat. It will be to his benefit if you can every now and then give him some raw meat as well. Make sure to see that he has a constant supply of fresh, cool water.

Exercise:

McNab Shepherds are very active dogs and they are going to require quite a bit of physical exercise as well as mental stimulation. They are dogs who have been used to herding livestock and he loves this busy life. It is why he wouldn’t be happy living in the city but is better suited to farm life or in a home with a large garden. Long walks and hikes will suit him as well as swimming and joining in every game there is.

Grooming:

The McNab is considered to be a low maintenance dog and grooming the short thick coat will be required twice a week. Always check around the eyes and ears as well as inside the mouth for problems and infections.

Exercise:

istrian sheepdog dogs - caringThis is a dog that is used to guarding his flock and he will need to be in a home that has a fair sized garden. He can adapt to life in the city or to the countryside, but wherever he is, he will need sufficient exercise. Take him with you on your walks or hikes and give him some rope- and ball games.

General Care:

Wherever you live in the world, when the Winter winds howl and blow in icy rain or snow, a dog is at an increased risk of illness. You decided to have a dog in your home and it is your responsibility to care for him. Winter weather is downright unpleasant and dangerous for most pets.

Bring your pet in during such weather and provide him with a warm, dry sleeping space. During hot weather, make sure your pet has a cool, shady spot to lie down in, out of the boiling sun. Whatever weather you're experiencing, your pet should never ever be without a constant supply of fresh, cool water.

Provide him with excellent food that is full of vitamins and minerals to keep him healthy. Learn to know what human foods can be toxic for him and cause him digestive problems.

Grooming:

Your double coated Istrian Sheepdog will need a thorough brushing at least twice a week because of his dense, double coat. He does shed and isn't a hypoallergenic dog. His thick coat can tangle easily if it isn't properly brushed and maintained.

Clip his nails when and if they grow long. Other grooming aspects for this attractive dog require checking his ears for infection and also checking his teeth as dental disease can lead to a host of serious illnesses in your dog.

Basic Information

Group:
Working dog
Working dog
Origin:
United States
Slovenia
Height Male:
40 - 64 cm
15 - 26 inches
54 - 63 cm
21 - 25 inches
Height Female:
40 - 64 cm
15 - 26 inches
54 - 63 cm
21 - 25 inches
Weight Male:
14 - 30 kg
30 - 67 pounds
26 - 40 kg
57 - 89 pounds
Weight Female:
14 - 30 kg
30 - 67 pounds
26 - 40 kg
57 - 89 pounds
Life Span:
13 - 15 Years
10 - 12 Years
Litter Size:
1 - 7
3 - 6
Size:
Medium dog
Medium dog
Other Names:
McNab Shepherd, McNab Collie
Karst Sheepdog
Colors Available:
Black or red with white feet, white tipped tails and white markings around the face
Dark and Light shades of Grey
Coat:
Short and dense
Long, thick and harsh
Shedding:
Minimal
Moderate, Seasonal
Temperament:
Affectionate, Alert, Cheerful, Curious, Friendly, Gentle, Independent, Intelligent, Lively, Loving, Loyal, Outgoing, Playful, Protective, Responsive, Social, Stubborn, Territorial
Affectionate, Aggressive, Alert, Cheerful, Courageous, Curious, Energetic, Friendly, Independent, Intelligent, Lively, Loving, Loyal, Outgoing, Playful, Protective, Responsive, Social, Stubborn, Territorial
Grooming:
Low maintenance
Moderate maintenance
Trainability:
Easy
Easy
Hypoallergenic:
No
No
Kids Friendly:
No
Yes
New Owners Friendly:
Yes
Yes

Comparison with other breeds

  1. Sakhalin Husky vs McNab - Breed Comparison
  2. Portuguese Water Dog vs McNab - Breed Comparison
  3. Puli vs McNab - Breed Comparison
  4. McNab vs American Bulldog - Breed Comparison
  5. McNab vs Border Collie - Breed Comparison
  6. McNab vs Alaskan Husky - Breed Comparison
  7. McNab vs Catahoula Leopard - Breed Comparison
  8. McNab vs German Pinscher - Breed Comparison
  9. McNab vs Aidi - Breed Comparison
  10. McNab vs Griffon Bleu de Gascogne - Breed Comparison
  11. McNab vs Borador - Breed Comparison
  12. McNab vs German Spaniel - Breed Comparison
  13. McNab vs Canadian Eskimo Dog - Breed Comparison
  14. McNab vs Finnish Lapphund - Breed Comparison
  15. McNab vs Berger Blanc Suisse - Breed Comparison
  16. McNab vs Griffon Nivernais - Breed Comparison
  17. McNab vs Hokkaido - Breed Comparison
  18. McNab vs Australian Kelpie - Breed Comparison
  19. McNab vs Griffon Fauve de Bretagne - Breed Comparison
  20. McNab vs Basque Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  21. McNab vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  22. McNab vs Jamthund - Breed Comparison
  23. McNab vs Karelian Bear Dog - Breed Comparison
  24. McNab vs Karelo-Finnish Laika - Breed Comparison
  25. McNab vs Kintamani - Breed Comparison
  26. Sakhalin Husky vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  27. Portuguese Water Dog vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  28. Puli vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  29. Porcelaine vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  30. Hokkaido vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  31. Petit Bleu de Gascogne vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  32. Pumi vs Istrian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  33. Istrian Sheepdog vs American Bulldog - Breed Comparison
  34. Istrian Sheepdog vs Border Collie - Breed Comparison
  35. Istrian Sheepdog vs Alaskan Husky - Breed Comparison
  36. Istrian Sheepdog vs Catahoula Leopard - Breed Comparison
  37. Istrian Sheepdog vs German Pinscher - Breed Comparison
  38. Istrian Sheepdog vs Aidi - Breed Comparison
  39. Istrian Sheepdog vs Griffon Bleu de Gascogne - Breed Comparison
  40. Istrian Sheepdog vs Borador - Breed Comparison
  41. Istrian Sheepdog vs German Spaniel - Breed Comparison
  42. Istrian Sheepdog vs Canadian Eskimo Dog - Breed Comparison
  43. Istrian Sheepdog vs Finnish Lapphund - Breed Comparison
  44. Istrian Sheepdog vs Berger Blanc Suisse - Breed Comparison
  45. Istrian Sheepdog vs Griffon Nivernais - Breed Comparison
  46. Istrian Sheepdog vs Australian Kelpie - Breed Comparison
  47. Istrian Sheepdog vs Griffon Fauve de Bretagne - Breed Comparison
  48. Istrian Sheepdog vs Basque Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  49. Istrian Sheepdog vs Canaan Dog - Breed Comparison

View/Compare Breeds

Popular Dog Breeds